Growing up, one of the best movies I had ever watched was Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring. I had always wanted to read the original book, but it never really happened until last year (As of the time of writing), and wow. Let me tell you, I was incredibly surprised by the story. Here, ladies and gentlemen, is my review of The Fellowship of the Ring, the first book in the Lord of the Rings trilogy.
How it Settings:
Lord of the Rings is very beautiful sounding. The settings are described, mostly, in great detail, specially in the earlier parts of the story, while the main characters are in the Shire. As the story progresses, there's less local narrative, but there's plenty of 'over there stands a mountain, and next to it a river' which are irrelevant to the story it tells. Even though the book is incredibly detailed, sometimes details are lost in the sea of words, leading to feelings of places being disjointed, which happened to me far too often. I found myself rereading some lines, other times finding myself lost in the places he described, as some connections between everything are either minimal, or drowned in large paragraphs. I understand that writing changes throughout the years, but even for old stories, the narrative related directly to the settings and locations seem to be uneven and sometimes just unbalanced, as places like the Shire have directions such as 'beyond the river', but other places completely lack details.
How it Characters:
When it comes to characters, they are two dimensional for the most part, there to serve an archetype. This is not to say that some characters, Aragorn and Sam primarily, are very deep in their execution, but Frodo, for example, lacks much in the way of personality, resembling more a silent protagonist for the reader to 'replace' in their minds. Not only that, but the narrative sometimes introduces characters name-first, not explaining who that character is, or where they came from or anything. Beyond that, there's a particular character included that just screams 'Deus Ex Machina', existing to save the characters from certain events that occurred. This character never appears again after the few chapters he helps the main characters in, and is only mentioned once (Not explained) later on in the book.
How it Plot:
The plot is a classic case of 'magical item that must be taken to a distant destination and along the way the heroes traverse various locations each with a final confrontation of sorts'. This is not a bad thing, mind you, it's just a pretty generic story, accompanied by a few cliches that this story might've been the original birther of them. There's not a lot to say about the plot beyond that, mind you, as the story is pretty straightforward and doesn't deviate from the previously stated.
Verdict and Conclusion:
Okay, so, even though there's a lot of not-necessarily-good stuff about the story, this is a solid 3 and a half out of 5, because what's there is amazing. When Tolkien hits the spot, there's no one that can match him, but that doesn't mean there aren't flaws to this story. Those Flaws don't make this a bad story in any way, as it's still one of the best stories I've read, but I genuinely couldn't help but point out the mistakes. Anyone who reads the story can see the positives, however, as they're massive. And there you have it, a solid right above the middle for Tolkien's first Lord of the Rings book.